Wednesday, January 23, 2013

How To Write A Better Book Review

How To Write A Better Book Review

I've compiled this article on my search to find ways to better improve the book reviews that I do here on my blog. I felt that my reviewing skills were lacking compared to others in regards to details. My reviews are very simple, but I would like to give the reader more. So here's my list to write better book reviews.

1) Don't read the book. At least, not yet. Instead, start by looking at it. Look for clues to the nature of the book you'll be reading. Is it a richly manufactured item aimed at collectors? What does the cover illustration indicate the book will be about? What sort of blurbs are included? How is it categorized by the publisher? All of these will tell you the book's target audience.

2) Don't read the book. At least, not quite yet. Instead, open the book and flip through it. Look at how the words are arranged on the pages. Start with the largest distinctions—the number of pages, the number of chapters, and so on. Then move to the size of paragraphs, how much of the book is dialogue, etc. This will tell you about the book's readability and how the author structured the book.

3) Build a framework for taking notes. You always focus better if you have something specific to look for and markers to pay attention to along the way. Start with the simplest things—the number of chapters, for example—and then move on to more complex tasks, such as questions you'll want to answer: "What makes this book a classic?" or "What made this book 'speak for a generation' like the introduction said it did?"

4) Read the book. And as you do so...

5) Pay attention. That isn't a disciplinary command like, "Don't let your mind wander!" Instead, pay attention to your reading experience. This is the first real challenge for most people. What caught your attention, and when were you bored? When was the book suspenseful? Which characters did you like, and why?

6) Review the book and take notes that let you explain its effects. This is the second tough step for most people. Remember that note-taking framework you built earlier? Now's the time to fill it in. Flip back through the book and write brief, purposeful notes. What happens in the first chapter—and what was its effect on you as a reader? When you passed from one part of the book to the next—chapter, section, or setting—what kept your attention? This is the part most people neglect, but it lays the foundation for the rest of the book review, so keep at it until you can do the following:
  • Explain how the book as a whole affected you.
  • Explain how the author achieved the effects he or she did.
  • Explain the relationship between form and content.
  • If it is fiction, explain the function of each character in the novel.
  • Explain the characters' relationships to one another.

7) Sum up the book. This is the easy part, and half of what most people think a book review is. Put the book in a nutshell. Keep summarizing it until you've got everything covered clearly. Use that to start your review.

8) Pass judgment. This is the other half of a book review for most people. Is this book good or bad? This is the time for you to say so. Put that second in your review—but use your notes from earlier to explain why and to make your judgment persuasive. Give specific examples, and move from passing judgment to explaining the book. That comes third.

9) Put the book in context. You might have been able to get this information from looking at the book's cover and introduction, or you might need to do a little research. What categories does this book fall into? Is it science fiction or fantasy? Is it the first of its kind or an imitation? The author's first book or fifteenth? Spend some time relating this book to others in its category to further explain the book and your judgment of it.

10) Check your aim. You've written your review. Now's the time to step back and apply this sort of reasoning to your own review. Did you explain every major aspect of the book? What was your target audience?'re done!

Hope these tips were helpful. If you have any tips to add that you use to write great book reviews, please feel free to share.

Read an excerpt of CULTURE SHOCK, my debut YA novel coming out next month.

Visit my website to learn more about me:

Follow me on Twitter or Pinterest: @JeanettePekala

Happy Reading & Writing,



  1. I always tend to do that when reviewing :) Well... most of it, lol.
    I also write my review about 50% (usually more) and then revise it later so I can have most of the book fresh in mind. Or at least have a bit of a start before I forget later.

    ~Sophia @ Bookwyrming Thoughts

    1. Revising and editing are definitely essential. Thanks for the additional tip.

  2. Nice tips, Jeanette. I've been writing reviews on Goodreads, but they're always short and not too detailed. I decided to start reviewing books on my blog and I've found this post helpful. I'll be applying the tips to my reviews :) Thanks!!

    1. I'm glad this post has helped you. I know I found these tips helpful and hopefully I'll be able to produce a better book review in the future.

  3. Great tips! I haven't written a review for my blog yet, but I am definitely planning on it. I feel a little more confident going into the reviewing process with your advice. Thanks!

    1. Thanks. Good to hear. Good luck with your first review.